In April 2024, Unit 401 at the Beau Rivage, 9103 Atlantic Avenue, sold for $379,900. It was one of the first units sold after the motel became a condominium. The deed for its resale was recorded on October 28, 2026, at $420,000. That is a gain of $40,100 in about two and a half years. In the same summer, the original developer was still selling units in the same building at almost the same price. Beau Rivage LLC sold Unit 309 for $419,900 on July 31, 2026, three months before the 401 resale closed.
The two sales were $100 apart, and that gap explains this market. When a Wildwood Crest motel changes hands, it can be sold off room by room, cleared for new houses, or kept as a motel. Each outcome adds a different kind of home at a different price. In the condo version, owners who resell have closed close to what the developer was getting for its own units at the time.
The Beau Rivage, Sale by Sale
The Wildwood Video Archive reported the Beau Rivage conversion in October 2023. Its report said one family had run the motel for 32 years and was retiring. All 48 units were listed starting at $359,900, in one- and two-bedroom layouts, with a heated pool, assigned parking, gas grills and a laundry room.
The Cape May County Herald's Real Estate Intel deed record for the building shows how those units sold. Beau Rivage LLC appears as the seller on 34 deeds from March 2024 through July 2026.
| Period | Deeds from Beau Rivage LLC | Typical price range |
|---|---|---|
| March to December 2024 | 20 | $359,900 to $425,000, with three sales at $525,000 |
| April to November 2025 | 8 | $389,900 to $419,900 |
| May to July 2026 | 6 | $389,900 to $425,000, plus Unit 101 at $250,000 |
The table shows two trends. The developer sold fewer units each year, from 20 deeds in 2024 to eight in 2025 and six by the end of July 2026. The developer also raised the price. In spring 2024, standard units sold for $359,900 to $389,900. By late 2025, three units in a row sold at $419,900: Unit 212 in October, Unit 410 at the end of October, and Unit 310 in November. Apart from Unit 101 at $250,000, the developer's 2026 sales ranged from $389,900 for Unit 402 to $425,000 for Unit 411.
Resales Price Against the Developer
Three resales in the record show what a first buyer got back.
Unit 306 sold to Hand Avenue LLC for $369,900 on March 4, 2024. It resold for $395,000 on September 22, 2025. Unit 413 sold for $379,900 in March 2024 and resold for $425,000 on May 1, 2026. Unit 401 went from $379,900 to $420,000, as described above.
All three resales closed within a few thousand dollars of the prices Beau Rivage LLC was recording for its own units around the same time. The $425,000 resale of Unit 413 in May 2026 matched the developer's $425,000 sale of Unit 411 that June. Unit sizes and views differ, so the deeds do not prove a unit-for-unit match. The pattern is still consistent. While the developer was selling, a buyer looking at an owner's unit could also look at a developer's unit down the hall, and resale prices stayed in the same range as the developer's sales.
For a buyer, the developer's recorded sales are a useful comparison, because each one is in the public deed record with a date and a price. For an owner, the gains have been real but modest, about 7 to 12 percent on these three units over 18 to 31 months, and they followed the developer's price increases rather than moving ahead of them.
The buyer list also matters. LLC names appear on several deeds, including Hand Avenue LLC, Plumtree Properties LLC, Coolaf LLC, Orchid 104 LLC and Tomorrowland Holdings LLC. Tomorrowland Holdings bought Unit 101 for $250,000 in June 2026. If you are thinking about short-term rental income, some of the units around you are likely held for the same purpose. Our post on evaluating rental potential in Wildwood Crest covers that side of the decision.
The El Coronado at 8501 Atlantic Avenue is another motel condominium on the same avenue. A deed there was recorded at $299,900 in April 2025. The El Coronado condominium association recorded a master deed amendment there on December 31, 2025.
Where a Former Motel Room Sits in the Market
For about $420,000, a buyer gets a condo in a building that was a motel two summers ago. Wildwood Crest's overall numbers show how low that sits. In the Herald's deed data for October 14 through November 12, 2026, the town recorded 27 priced sales with a median of $635,000 and an average of $894,469. The average is far above the median because a small number of expensive sales pull it up. Two of those sales were on the same Atlantic Avenue corridor. Unit 501 at 8901 Atlantic Avenue sold for $1,550,000 in late October. In September, 8901 Atlantic Avenue sold for $1,250,000.
Across Cape May County, the New Jersey REALTORS October 2026 Local Market Update puts the median townhouse-condo sale price at $762,500 for January through October 2026. That figure is down 2.9% from the same period of 2025. The median for October 2026 alone was $955,000. A Beau Rivage unit near $420,000 costs a little more than half the county's year-to-date condo median. The developer was still recording sales at $419,900 in July 2026, almost three years after the units first went on the market.
When the Motel Comes Down Instead
Demolition sends a motel site toward the opposite end of the price range. In May 2025, the Wildwood Crest Planning Board heard an application for the Ala Kai Motel at 8301 Atlantic Avenue. The owner, 8301 Atlantic Avenue, LLC, proposed demolishing the motel and splitting its 13,780-square-foot lot into three lots, two facing Atlantic Avenue and one facing Toledo Avenue, with a single-family house on each. According to the May 7, 2025 minutes, the board approved the three-lot subdivision.
The same owner group has a second motel at 401 E. Toledo Avenue, the Ala Kai North, formerly the Blue Marlin. On June 3, 2026, the board approved its subdivision into three lots for single-family homes. The approval was memorialized on July 1, 2026.
On both sites, a motel full of rooms becomes three lots for detached houses. Compare that with the Beau Rivage, where one motel added dozens of condos in the $400,000 range. The Ala Kai sites will add six single-family lots in total, on the same part of Atlantic Avenue where the $1 million-plus sales above took place.
When It Stays a Motel
Some motels change hands as motels. The Caribbean Motel at 5600 Ocean Avenue sold for $3,403,000. The deed was recorded July 1, 2026, from Coastal WC Inc to Caribbean Motel Holding Company and Christina Lacivita. The same deed database lists earlier Ocean Avenue motel sales: the Attache at 5707-11 Ocean Avenue for $4,230,000 in 2018, and the Crusader at 6101 Ocean Avenue for $5,600,000 in 2016. These sales sit far above anything in the condo or single-family figures above.
If you are deciding between an Atlantic Avenue condo and a detached home in the Crest, the three outcomes show where the new supply is coming from. The low-priced units have come from condo conversions. The next detached homes on Atlantic Avenue are planned for motel sites the board has approved for single-family lots. Our Wildwood Crest neighborhood page covers the rest of the town.
Questions Buyers Ask
Is the Beau Rivage developer still selling units? The most recent deed from Beau Rivage LLC in the Herald record is Unit 309, sold for $419,900 and recorded July 31, 2026. Check the current listings before you make an offer on a resale, because any developer unit still for sale gives you a direct price comparison.
What will New Jersey Avenue look like while I'm house hunting this winter? Cape May County's $13 million reconstruction of New Jersey Avenue began September 7, 2026. Phase 1, from Rambler Road to Columbine Road, is scheduled to finish by May 15, 2027. One direction of traffic stays open while the other is detoured. Phase 2 runs from September 2027 to May 2028 and includes Crest Station, a parking area and community event space between Sweetbriar Road and Aster Road. The Cape May County Herald reported in October that Mayor Don Cabrera expects the downtown work to be finished by summer 2028.
Can I find out what a specific unit sold for? Yes. The Herald's Real Estate Intel database posts recorded deeds with dates and prices. Prices at Beau Rivage depend heavily on the unit and on whether the seller is the developer or a private owner.
If you're comparing a Beau Rivage unit with a new house on a former motel lot, or wondering how your own Atlantic Avenue condo would price while developer units are still selling, Greg Davis Luxury Homes can talk it through with you. Schedule a consultation and bring the address you have in mind.